ApunKaChoice : Bollywood


Hera-PheriThe decline of comedy in Bollywood
10th Aug 2008  22.30 IST
By Nikhil Kumar  

Can you recall the last time you saw a real good Bollywood comedy with a credible story and a cohesive script?

I can't. Because comedy in Bollywood has of late become synonymous with everything that is nonsensical, campy and over-the-top. Just cram in as many gags as you can; to hell with the script. Rope in a superstar with a charm to pull the crowds, cast a stunner opposite him and - if the producer's pocket permits - get some American or English band or singer to croon a song in between. And voila, a corny comedy is ready to be served. Sadly, that seems to be the mantra of filmmakers nowadays. And, to be fair, there's not much wrong in it when there are people to lap it up. The only trouble is that such no-brainers become a norm and spell a slow death of the comedy genre. And that's no laughing matter.

Here's how.

Take, for instance, a classic comedy like 'Chupke Chupke'. At the bottom of the film is a tight script with properly fleshed out characters. Not even a single gag is deliberately squeezed in and yet there are hilarious moments aplenty. This seamless interweaving of gags into the backbone of the story was what the real mastery of making a comedy film used to be. And such movies have great repeat-view value. You can watch them again and again and still find joy out of the known jokes. Be it 'Chalti Ka Naam Gaadi' or 'Golmaal', 'Satte Pe Satta' or 'Jaane Bhi Do Yaaron', Hera-Pheri or Lage Raho Munnabhai - such films become memorable classics.

The same can't be said of the present-day monstrosities like Welcome or Partner which have turned the whole way of making comedy films on its head. The script or the story isn't important at all. Nor is of any significance the progression in the plot. Such trivial things are secondary. What matters is the number of jokes (not necessarily their quality or originality). The more the better. Depending on these gags, the situations in these films are moulded and contrived, and at times superficially tagged on like some appendage.

Almost all the recent comedies by Anees Bazmee qualify the aforesaid formula. They are all nothing but a series of gags strung together to give the semblance of a story. The only reason they succeeded is because they had a charismatic star to carry off the stupidity with élan.

The same goes for Singh Is Kinng , which is much much better than Bazmee's previous torture (Welcome) but way way below what can convincingly be called a true-blue laugh riot. Yep.

What works in the film is Akshay Kumar and Akshay Kumar alone. Take Akshay out and the film falls flat on its face with all its goofiness and buffoonery. I know these remarks may raise many a hackle, but guys please consider this for a moment.

For how long can filmmakers continue to conceal their sub-standard product behind charismatic stars and big production houses? A no-brainer comedy once in a while isn't a bad thing, but should comedy necessarily have no brains? Does it have to be senseless and stupid to make you laugh? Is intelligent comedy a bad, forbidden thing that we should not expect from our filmmakers?

The truth is - forgive the cliché - comedy is a serious business and a difficult one at that. And it takes a real master like Kundan Shah or Hrishikesh Mukherjee or even Manmohan Desai to get about this business.

Lage Raho Munnabhai
view Welcome videos (new)
view Partner videos (new)
view Anees Bazmee videos (new)
view Singh Is Kinng videos (new)
view Akshay Kumar videos (new)
view Kundan Shah videos (new)
view Hrishikesh Mukherjee videos (new)
view Manmohan Desai videos (new)

Now Trending : Salman Khan | Shahrukh Khan | Ranbir Kapoor | Priyanka Chopra Aishwarya Rai | Katrina Kaif | Kareena Kapoor | Priyanka Chopra | Alia Bhatt | Surveen Chawla | New Hindi Movies

Snapshot: Shahid Kapoor celebrates Rakhi with sister Sanah
Shahid and Sanah celebrate Raksha Bandhan
Pix: Shah Rukh Khan wraps up ‘Dilwale’ song shoot with Kajol in Iceland
Pix: Salman Khan celebrates Rakhi with sister
Katrina Kaif says her blood boils on being called Ranbir’s girlfriend!
Gorgeous Jacqueline Fernandez covers Cine Blitz
Do you like Sidharth Malhotra’s quaint look for ‘Baar Baar Dekho’
Esha Gupta brings sexy back as Maxim cover girl
Salman Khan chops Sooraj Pancholi-Athiya Shetty kiss from ‘Hero’
Watch Bollywood’s first stop-motion song: ‘Lip To Lip De Kissiyan’ has Imran, Kangana on kissing spree
You won’t believe what Katrina Kaif said about her marriage plan with Ranbir Kapoor
Check out the new title of Katrina Kaif, Sidharth Malhotra’s movie ‘Kal Jisne Dekha’
Watch song: 'Khoya Khoya' from 'Hero' tugs at your heartstrings
Hollywood Reporter names Priyanka Chopra as one of the top 10 TV stars to watch out for
All is well in my paradise: John Abraham
'Phantom' movie review: A revenge you wish was smarter


ECARDS > Valentines Day, New Year, Diwali, Birthday, Valentines, Love, Christmas
CardWeaver.com > Birthday, Holi


celebs » wallpapers » the celeb A-Z
who's in » Freida Pinto | Anushka Sharma | Katrina Kaif | Deepika Padukone | Ranbir Kapoor | Dev Patel | Aishwarya Rai | Abhishek Bachchan | Imran Khan | Shahrukh Khan | Salman Khan | Aamir Khan | Hrithik Roshan | Akshay Kumar | Zayed Khan | Saif Ali Khan | John Abraham | Shahid Kapur | Kareena Kapoor | Vidya Balan | Priyanka Chopra | Rani Mukherjee | Mallika Sherawat | Bipasha Basu | Preity Zinta | Kajol | Neha Dhupia | Sameera Reddy | Juhi Chawla | Karisma Kapoor | Madhuri Dixit | Chitrangada Singh | Payal Rohatgi | Sneha Ullal | Mahima Chaudhary | Meghna Naidu | Rakhi Sawant | Bhumika Chawla | Lisa Ray | Dimple Kapadia | Ayesha Takia | Dia Mirza | Sushmita Sen | Amisha Patel | Esha Deol | Amrita Rao | Amrita Arora | Genelia D'Souza | Arjun Rampal | Amitabh Bachchan | Vivek Oberoi | Raima Sen | Riya Sen | Rekha | Rimi Sen | Nigar Khan | Tanushree Dutta | Yana Gupta | Shilpa Shetty | Celina Jaitley | Sonam Kapoor | Neha Oberoi | Nisha Rawal | Manjari Fadnis | Kamal Haasan | Rajnikant | Asin | Sanjay Dutt | Shahid Kapoor | Sherlyn Chopra | Farhan Akhtar | Prachi Desai | Mandira Bedi | Shahana Goswami | Konkona Sen Sharma | Kangana Ranaut | Mugdha Godse | Masumeh Makhija | Minissha Lamba | Nandana Sen | Malaika Arora | Shweta Kumar | Namitha | Kalki Koechlin | Mahi Gill | Shakeela | Lara Dutta | A R Rahman | Trisha | Shruti Haasan | Neetu Chandra | Shriya Saran | Padma Lakshmi | Emma Watson | Kelly Clarkson | Britney Spears | Anne Hathaway | Anjana Sukhani | Tila Tequila | Soha Ali Khan | Priyamani | Sonal Chauhan | Vaishali Desai | Jackky Bhagnani | Kristen Stewart | Robert Pattinson | Neil Nitin Mukesh | Shiney Ahuja | more...