site  movies  celebs  music  news  showtimes  user  
Hello, Stranger Login | Sign up
ApunKaChoice » Article » Much ado about Shahrukh Khan’s 'Challa' being copied!

Much ado about Shahrukh Khan’s 'Challa' being copied!

Is 'Challa' from 'Jab Tak Hai Jaan' copied? We don’t think so!
By Nikhil Kumar
Mon, Oct 08, 2012 12:09:31 GMT

There’s much hullabaloo over the Shahrukh Khan track ‘Challa’ from Jab Tak Hai Jaan being copied from the Eagle Eye Cherry track ‘Save Tonight’. However, the similarities are few and far between, we think.

Similar strumming pattern and a few similar chords don’t make two songs the same. If that were the case, half of western music would be labeled copied from the other half. It’s like saying that Bruno Mars’ ‘The Lazy Song’ is copied from Bob Dylan’s ‘Knocking on Heaven’s Door’ because the chord progression (G-D-C in this case) happens to be the same.

Now, ‘Challa’ from Jab Tak Hai Jaan begins with brisk strumming following which the drums kick in. What’s got the detractors confused is the fact that the chord progression of ‘Challa’ is similar to that of ‘Save Tonight’ (Am-F-C-G), but as the song progresses, the chords too vary and the two tracks become as different as chalk and cheese.

By the logic of the detractors, all the songs with the Am-F-C-G progression would be copies of each other, some being Bon Jovi’s “It’s My Life”, Eminem’s “Not Afraid”, or Heart’s “Alone”.

If our assertion sounds mumbo-jumbo to you, rest assured that the melody combinations that any single progression posits could be so diverse that many different compositions could be belted out of the same progression.

The upshot: A R Rahman isn’t shorn of talent or ideas to copy songs when he can create award winning numbers.

Enjoy both the songs below and check out for yourself if ‘Challa’ is copied from ‘Save Tonight’.

‘Challa’ from Jab Tak Hai Jaan:

‘Save Tonight’ by Eagle Eye Cherry

Preview: ‘Taken 2’ promises thrill and action!
First trailer: Rana Daggubati and Nayanthara star in ‘Krishnam Vande Jagadgurum’
Pix: Shah Rukh Khan poses on top of a car despite bad knee!
Pix: Shah Rukh Khan poses on top of a car despite bad knee!
Pix: When Shah Rukh Khan visited Salman Khan a day before verdict
Pix: When Shah Rukh Khan visited Salman Khan a day before verdict
When Shah Rukh Khan put himself up for ‘auction’
When Shah Rukh Khan put himself up for ‘auction’
New Look: Shah Rukh Khan as a warrior in 'Atharva'
New Look: Shah Rukh Khan as a warrior in 'Atharva'
Tags :
comments powered by Disqus

Now Trending : Salman Khan | Shahrukh Khan | Ranbir Kapoor | Aishwarya Rai | Katrina Kaif | Kareena Kapoor | Priyanka Chopra | Poonam Pandey | Sherlyn Chopra | Alia Bhatt | New Hindi Movies

Photo Galleries 

Esha Gupta walks the ramp at LFW 2015

LFW: Arjun Rampal looks a heartthrob on the ramp

Ileana D’Cruz scorches ramp at LFW 2015

Pix: Lovely Kriti Sanon wows on the ramp at LFW Winter/Festive

Aditi Rao Hydari, Dia Mirza, Shriya Saran at LFW 2015 grand finale

Stunning Kareena Kapoor turns showstopper for LFW Winter/Festive 2015 grand finale

LFW’s big moment: Shahid Kapoor, Mira Rajput hand-in-hand at Masaba’s show

Pix: Shah Rukh Khan wraps up ‘Dilwale’ song shoot with Kajol in Iceland

Hero Wallpapers

Bajirao Mastani Wallpapers

Jazbaa Wallpapers

Raees Wallpapers

Bajrangi Bhaijaan Wallpapers

Katti Batti Wallpapers
Hot Celebrities 

Hrithik Roshan

Aishwarya Rai

Nargis Fakhri
New Movies 


All Is Well

Manjhi - The Mountain Man

Hrithik Roshan, Katrina Kaif sizzle together in song 'Meherbaan'

'Finding Fanny' song 'Shake Your Bootiya'

Sonam Kapoor grooving to the party anthem ‘Abhi Toh Party Shuru Hui Hai’

Hrithik Roshan and Katrina Kaif wow in ‘Bang Bang’ song video 'Tu Meri'

Shahid Kapoor in the 'Haider' song ‘Bismil’

‘Raja Natwarlal’ song ‘Namak Paare’ featuring Emraan Hashmi, Humaima Malick

Copyright © ApunKaChoice.com
ApunKaChoice.com : Latest Bollywood News, Bollywood Movies Reviews, Bollywood Wallpapers
privacy policy
Partner Sites : Sports - CricketZone - IndiaExpress.com [ Mobiles Festivals Bikes Cars ] - CardWeaver

photo gallery - new movies - celebs - wallpapers - the celeb A-Z - News & Gossip - Music - Video - Hot Topics
Anushka Sharma - Katrina Kaif - Kareena Kapoor - Priyanka Chopra - Deepika Padukone - Sonakshi Sinha - Aishwarya Rai - Poonam Pandey - Sherlyn Chopra
Salman Khan ( Bigg Boss 6 ) - Shahrukh Khan - Shahid Kapoor - Hrithik Roshan - Aamir Khan - Ranbir Kapoor